November 17, 2026
In this episode of the Strasbourg Observers Podcast, Eva Brems speaks with Anne Heinisch, postdoctoral researcher at the Cluster of Excellence “Transforming Human Rights” at Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, about the role of evidence in the proceedings of the European Court of Human Rights. Drawing on their doctoral research, which combined case law analysis with ethnographically informed fieldwork at the Court’s Registry and interviews with key actors and was conducted as part of Prof. Marie-Bénédicte Dembour’s ERC-funded DISSECT project, they discuss how the Court approaches the assessment and establishment of facts, the development of its evidentiary practices over time, and the challenges of an approach that lacks a coherent evidentiary regime. The conversation also explores how caseload pressure, efficiency imperatives and political criticism shape the Court’s treatment of evidence, raising broader questions about the administration of justice in Strasbourg and the safeguards needed to ensure fair and thorough proceedings.
If you want to read more about the topics discussed, we point you to the following publications:
Anne Heinisch, ‘The Evidentiary Practice of the European Court of Human Rights: Critical Reflections on its Historical, Institutional and Political Underpinnings’ (PhD thesis, Ghent University, 2025)
Corina Heri, ‘Evidence: European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR)’, Max Planck Encyclopedia of International Procedural Law[MPEiPro] (Oxford University Press 2018)
Philip Leach, ‘Fact-Finding: European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR)’, Max Planck Encylopedia of International Procedural Law[MPEiPro] (Oxford University Press 2018)
Michael O’Boyle, ‘Proof: European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR)’, Max Planck Encyclopedia of International Procedural Law [MPEiPro] (Oxford University Press 2018)
Special Issue: The Evidentiary System of the European Court of Human Rights in Critical Perspective, edited by Marie-Bénédicte Dembour.
Alexandra Ellen Hansen, Facts Before the European Court of Human Rights (Nomos 2022)
Anne Heinisch, ‘Russia and the Strasbourg Court: evidentiary challenges arising from Russia’s expulsion from the Council of Europe’ (Strasbourg Observers, 2 June 2022)
Alix Schlüter, Beweisfragen in Der Rechtsprechung Des Europäischen Gerichtshofs Für Menschenrechte(Springer 2019)
Torsten Stirner, The Procedural Law Governing Facts and Evidence in International Human Rights Proceedings (Brill | Nijhoff 2021)